Gov. Times

Owens Breaks 4 Campaign Promises in first hour in Congress

 0
WaPo

Work begins on Flight 93 memorial

 0
CNN

Dead wrong: Man attends own funeral after mix-up over body’s ID

 0
Politico

Palin: Dems will apply abortion mind-set to elderly

0
McClatchy

Obama leaning toward 34,000 more troops for Afghanistan

0
All Headlines »
 

Breaking: Federal appeals court rules FBI raid on “Fridge” Jefferson’s office was unconstitutional

Posted by: Sister Toldjah on August 3, 2007 at 11:41 am

Via AP:

WASHINGTON — The FBI violated the Constitution when agents raided U.S. Rep. William Jefferson’s office last year and viewed legislative documents, a federal appeals court ruled Friday.

The court ordered the Justice Department to return any privileged documents it seized from the Louisiana Democrat’s office on Capitol Hill. The court did not order the return of all the documents seized in the raid.

Jefferson argued that the raid trampled on congressional independence. The Justice Department said that declaring the search unconstitutional would essentially prohibit the FBI from ever looking at a lawmaker’s documents.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, nonetheless, sided with Jefferson on the constitutional issue.

“The review of the Congressman’s paper files when the search was executed exposed legislative material to the Executive,” and violated the Constitution, the court wrote. “The Congressman is entitled to the return of documents that the court determines to be privileged.”

Here’s the PDF of the opinion.

I think we have a judge here who is trying to find a law that doesn’t exist, but I’m not a legal expert and will defer to the opinions of the esteemed legal team at the Volokh Conspiracy, where I’m sure we’ll see something on this later today.

Prior:

In: Breaking News Stories, Congress, Law/Judiciary, Other US Courts | Email This Post | Print This

RSS feed for comments on this post.

2 Responses to “Breaking: Federal appeals court rules FBI raid on “Fridge” Jefferson’s office was unconstitutional”

Comments

  1. Vatar says:
    August 3, 2007 at 1:53 pm

    The way I read it this decision is pretty meaningless. They have to give back his legislative-related documents. The real decision will come later when this goes to trial and the defense tries to get all the rest of the evidence thrown out because some papers were collected “illegally.”

  2. CavalierX says:
    August 4, 2007 at 4:46 am

    This is a case of the elites closing ranks to cover their own butts. William “Chilly Willy” Jefferson is not the first politician to keep incriminating evidence of his wrongdoing in his office, and the rest of the Capitol Hill Gang know full well he won’t be the last.