Why the MSM treats Sandra Fluke differently than they did Joe the Plumber

Posted by: ST on March 7, 2012 at 6:53 pm

Jonah Goldberg pegs it:

You may recall that when Joe Wurzelbacher was approached by Barack Obama entirely accidentally, he became something of a political celebrity for having a philosophical disagreement with the president over spreading the wealth around and all that. Before long, the mainstream press went to battle stations to discredit the man.


Meanwhile, here’s Sandra Fluke a 30-year-old law student and committed political operative and activist. And yet the mainstream press can’t muster the slightest skepticism about her efforts.


Still, I think the comparison is interesting in numerous ways. When average citizens are thrust into the political debate, they are heroes — if they confirm prevailing liberal arguments. When they run against the grain of the preferred narrative, they are ground down, caricatured, and treated to corrosive media skepticism.

Obviously, there are differences between the two cases. Some are relevant, some aren’t. If you think Fluke is special because she’s a woman, that’s awfully chivalrous of you (and I might even agree!). But such old-fashioned deference to the delicate sensibilities of women is not exactly a pose we’re told feminists of Fluke’s stripe support. Moreover, as Kirsten Powers notes in an excellent column, such deference to the fairer sex is not a standard liberals support when the woman in question is a conservative.

Selective vetting, frankly, stinks — as we all were reminded during the 2008 presidential campaign season, and again now.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

2 Responses to “Why the MSM treats Sandra Fluke differently than they did Joe the Plumber”


  1. Drew the Infidel says:

    This is the usual MO of the left; demonize everyone you disagree with. There is a reason for this. They know full well if their points were ever debated in an honest fashion they would blow up in their faces like bubble gum.

  2. Brontefan says:

    And I wonder if some well-meaning Democratic public employee will do a search on Ms. Fluke to see is there is anything telling in her background? This double standard is totally outrageous. We have a sitting president who brags about bypassing Congress and doing all he can to subvert the Constitution. We have a sitting Supreme Court Justice who believes the South African Constitution is so much better than ours. What is happening to our country?