Mean House Republicans make Obama and Reid cry

Posted by: Phineas on December 13, 2011 at 9:41 pm

**Posted by Phineas

And they did it while pursuing intelligent, job-creating energy policy:

Defiant Republicans pushed legislation through the House Tuesday night that would keep alive Social Security payroll tax cuts for some 160 million Americans at President Barack Obama’s request — but also would require construction of a Canada-to-Texas oil pipeline that has sparked a White House veto threat.

Passage, on a largely party-line vote of 234-193, sent the measure toward its certain demise in the Democratic-controlled Senate, triggering the final partisan showdown of a remarkably quarrelsome year of divided government.

The legislation “extends the payroll tax relief, extends and reforms unemployment insurance and protects Social Security — without job-killing tax hikes,” Republican House Speaker John Boehner declared after the measure had cleared.

Referring to the controversy over the Keystone XL pipeline, he added, “Our bill includes sensible, bipartisan measures to help the private sector create jobs.”

On a long day of finger pointing, however, House Democrats accused Republicans of protecting “millionaires and billionaires, ” and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., derided the GOP-backed pipeline provision as “ideological candy” for the tea party-set.

Harry’s just mad that the ball is in his court, now, and the situation is lose-lose for him and his Munificent Sun King. Here’s the background:

The Keystone XL pipeline would cross roughly 1,700 miles from Canada’s tar-sands deposits to the Gulf of Mexico in Texas. In addition to giving us access to a reliable supply of oil from a nearby friendly nation, estimates are that the pipeline will create anywhere from 5,000 to 20,000 jobs in the US, not to mention the consumer boost from disposable income. While there are environmental concerns, the State Department has declared them to be minimal. Sounds like a great deal, right?

Not if you’re Barack Obama and the Democrats, who need to pander to the environmentalist Left to shore up their base, it isn’t. Playing to the Green Luddites, Obama delayed a decision on Keystone until, oddly enough, after the election. I guess people who need jobs matter less than donations from the Sierra Club.

Back to the bill just passed.

Obama and the (Social) Democratic leadership had wanted a continuation of the payroll tax cut and an extension of unemployment insurance (which, btw, only worsens unemployment), all paid for by increasing taxes on those evil rich folks. The Republicans, on the other hand, understanding basic economics, wanted instead to pay for the cuts by imposing a federal wage freeze. They also wanted to pass legislation mandating approval for Keystone, since, well, Republicans actually care about people who are out of work and obtaining a reliable source of energy for the US, which would otherwise go to China. (There’s that Smart Power diplomacy, again.)

Obama had threatened to veto any legislation extending the payroll tax cuts if it included authorization for Keystone XL. He gambled that Republicans wouldn’t dare let themselves be seen as allowing a tax increase and a cutoff of unemployment benefits, something he and his allies figured would redound to the Democrats’ benefit.

Well, the Smartest President Ever bet wrong.

Here’s why the Democrats now find themselves in a pickle: the Republicans have passed a bill that

  1. Brings reliable energy to the US
  2. Creates thousands of real jobs (far more than the Stimulus ever did)
  3. Extends unemployment benefits (1) and payroll tax cuts
  4. and pays for them with a fiscally responsible wage freeze.

Now Reid has to either kill all that in the Senate (2), which will hand the Republicans a large club to beat Democratic incumbents with in 2012, or he has to pass it and send it to Obama, who will then have had his bluff called and face an ugly choice: tell thousands of unemployed American workers you don’t get a good job and, oh, by the way, the unemployment checks are going to stop, or sign the bill and look weak while ticking off the same environmental groups he had just bent the knee to.

Like I said, “lose -lose” for them. Darn.

Well played, House Republicans. Well played.

via Doug Powers

(1) Yeah, I just linked to an article showing how unemployment benefits retard job growth, but this is political reality. No party will vote to cut off those benefits in a rotten economy. And that’s why Obama will not veto this bill.
(2) Assuming he can hold his caucus together. Several of those vulnerable Democratic senators might well be tempted to defy their party leader and vote in favor of jobs “back home.”

(Crossposted at Public Secrets)

RSS feed for comments on this post.

8 Responses to “Mean House Republicans make Obama and Reid cry”


  1. Yorkshire says:

    But, but, but, this would really create REAL JOBS. not let’s pretend a tax cut will do it.

  2. Carlos says:

    Remind me again which party is using ideological purity in lieu of working for the benefit of the nation?

    Not that either Dingy or Duh-1 is ideologically pure. Both would trade whatever scruples they think they have for a vote.

  3. Drew the Infidel says:

    When did it become such a deadly sin in a capitalist society to aspire to self-improvement to the point of actually becoming another millionaire or billionaire? Hell, we need more of them! “Off your butt and on your feet; you make me nervous when you’re in your seat.”

  4. CZ says:


  5. bill glass says:

    As good conservatives, we should be in favor of the pipeline, but this’ll get spun big time. Not advocating for endless unemployment and ongoing payroll tax “holidays” will hurt us in 11 months. Play along ’til Nov., then stand on principle!!

  6. Tex says:

    I instantly was reminded of that famous song by The Police titled “Wrapped Around Your Finger” where at the end Sting sings “I will turn your flesh to alabaster, when you find your servant is your master”.

    Good one House Republicans! You’ve learned the Democratic Party’s tricks well!

  7. MarkJ says:

    I love this. Obama clearly delayed a decision on the pipeline to ensure campaign funds from both unions and eco-fascists continued to flow into his coffers. Now he’s faced with the prospect of losing at least one, and possibly both, income streams regardless of whether he signs or vetoes the bill.

    What a maroon.

  8. Carlos says:

    Lose income streams from unions and eco-terrorists? Ya gotta be kidding, Markj! The only way the unions would stop their flow of payola to Duh-1 is if one of their own stepped up and tried to run for prez.

    And the only reason eco-terror groups support him is because they know they don’t, can’t and never will have a viable candidate of their own, so owning the Democrap Party is the next best thing.