Iran can go on enriching, but music teachers must be stopped

Posted by: Phineas on December 7, 2013 at 7:42 pm

**Posted  by Phineas

music teacher violin

And you guys worry about Iran getting nuclear weapons? Fools! Thank God the FTC is there to protect us from the danger of unregulated violin instructors!

The Federal Trade Commission was created in 1914 in the age of oil barons and rail tycoons to bust the big trusts. Today, it’s busting a smaller enterprise – the Music Teachers National Association.

Last March, the FTC sent notice to the MTNA that it was under investigation for “anti-competitive practices.” At issue: a passage in the trade association’s ethics code that says teachers should not actively recruit from other teachers.

“We feel that that provision not only protects the students but ensures that teachers are going to get along well with their colleagues, ” says Gary Ingle, the MTNA’s executive director. 

Ingle says it’s a method of avoiding the rare conflict, where, for example, an accomplished student pianist may be approached after a competition by a rival instructor who promises to help the student win the next competition.

The FTC sees it as a threat to America’s consumers. 

There’s nothing in the rules that prevents a student from seeking out another teacher on their own, of course, and the FTC hasn’t shown how anyone has been harmed by a rule that prevents teachers from poaching each other’s students, but, apparently some bored bureaucrat decided that SOMETHING MUST BE DONE about this clear and present danger.

The MTNA has removed the rule while it figures out how to respond to the FTC’s investigation. So far, it’s amounted to a waste of member’s dues:

MTNA’s Ingle says that’s already happening. His 12-member staff in Cincinnati, Ohio has had to compile 17 years worth of records, including its by-laws, ethics code, journals, finances and membership to satisfy the FTC’s demands.

Sounds like what the IRS did to conservative groups, no? Beat them into submission by hitting them with burdensome documentation demands — and legal fees, should the group decide it needs representation.

Obama’s America: Where nothing is beneath the Federal government’s notice, except Iranian nukes.

via reader Lance

(Crossposted at Public Secrets)

RSS feed for comments on this post.


9 Responses to “Iran can go on enriching, but music teachers must be stopped”


  1. Carlos says:

    In the meantime, how many states have laws stating if one wants to work at a union shop-controlled enterprise, one must (by weight of law, no less) join the union.

    This administration and bureaucracy isn’t two-faced. They’ve got so many faces one can’t keep up with the count…

  2. Drew the Infidel says:

    This is where the O-bots get lost. The rule to which the music teachers were subscribing was a simple matter of honor and principle. The Iranian nuke deal is a failure on both those regards.

  3. JRob says:

    International Brotherhood of Magicians might well be next since our code of ethics prohibits putting a fellow magician in an untenable position.

  4. ALman says:


    Anything in the code about putting undesirable elected officials “in an untenable position”?

  5. Carlos says:


    Politicians are in an untenable situation simply by being politicians. No honor, no principle, no anything except greed, and lust for power.

  6. ALman says:

    Good one, Carlos. Nothing “magical” about them either. More like “A Nightmare on Elm Street”!

  7. Carlos says:

    Like my old drunk Hungarian uncle used to say, politicians are the nightmare of every free man…

  8. John A says:

    Doesn’t the lawyer’s Bar Association have a similar rule?