Over There – The MilBlog reaction
It’s not very favorable. Greyhawk has a roundup of MilBlog reactions. In a related post, he mentions an LA Times piece where 5 out of 6 LA Times staffers said the show’s characters "look real."
Here’s the show’s website, if you’re interested.
Evening update: Leopold Stotch at OTB says:
I didn’t catch the show, but it’s being marketed as a tool for understanding the human side of the war. It sounds like more Hollywood melodrama instead.
That’s pretty much my take on it, too.