Two Media-Declared “Historical Election Day Firsts” That Weren’t
There’s nothing the national mainstream political media love more on Election Day than for Republicans to suffer “bigly” at the polls and that’s exactly what happened Tuesday in the state of Virginia and beyond.
While politicos and pundits alike began speculating as to what this all meant for 2018, national mainstream media journos rushed to social media to declare “historical firsts” for election day. Here are just a few of many examples:
– Openly transgender candidates won races
– Minneapolis: First openly transgender person of color elected
– New Jersey: First Sikh mayor
– Seattle: First lesbian mayor
– Charlotte and St. Paul: First mayors of color
A night full of historic wins: https://t.co/nzCMTHjH3f pic.twitter.com/oU9mDt6uVc
— CNN (@CNN) November 8, 2017
New York Times Deputy Washington editor Jonathan Weisman:
After white supremacists declared their comeback, Virginia has an African American lieutenant governor, Charlotte has its 1st black mayor, & the Va. House of Delegates has a transgender member.
— Jonathan Weisman (@jonathanweisman) November 8, 2017
The Washington Post‘s Dave Weigel:
Danica Roem (D) has defeated Bob Marshall (R) in HD13. She will be America's first transgender state legislator.
— David Weigel (@daveweigel) November 8, 2017
Fact check on “first transgender legislator in a state house”? False:
Dear news editors:
Please update your stories to note that the first out trans person elected to public office was Althea Garrison in 1992, a black trans woman who won as a Republican in Massachusetts.
Thank you,
History https://t.co/XgocNKgUEM— Keith Boykin (@keithboykin) November 8, 2017
Was Tuesday’s winner, Democrat Vi Lyles, the “first African-American” to serve as mayor of Charlotte, North Carolina? No.
News editors also need to fix any mention of Charlotte "electing its first black mayor" because she's actually our 4th. Astonishing the misinfo out there. #Election2017 https://t.co/Hs5MaHg47X
— Sister Toldjah ? (@sistertoldjah) November 8, 2017
Harvey Gantt was Charlotte’s first black mayor, serving two terms from 1983-1987.
Anthony Foxx served as mayor of Charlotte from 2009 to 2013 before stepping down to work as Transportation Secretary in the Obama administration.
Patrick Cannon was Charlotte’s mayor for about 4 months – December 2013 to March 2014, before being arrested and pleading guilty on corruption charges.
Mayor-Elect Lyles is the first African-American woman to win a Charlotte mayoral race.
Subsequent reports on these “firsts” from some of the guilty news outlets corrected their earlier errors but their social media posts with the incorrect information remain up. Why? Perhaps showing off those thousands of retweets and likes they got on posts where the misinformation was first reported is more important than getting it right across the board?
While it’s to be expected that the Democratic Party’s biggest cheerleaders were ready to pop open the champagne bottles early as election results came in, their first priority should have been to verifying the information they were reporting.
Yes, there were several “firsts” Tuesday night, but the mainstream media getting a number of facts wrong sadly wasn’t one of them.